Insecticide resistance in flies: why “rotating products” often is not rotation
IRAC groups for the active substances used in livestock production, resistance mechanisms in Musca domestica, the reversibility of azamethiphos resistance and a working rotation scheme.
“We rotate our products” is a sentence that on most farms means something other than what is intended. Three different trade names are bought, used in turn, and the farm believes it is following an anti-resistance strategy. All three may belong to the same mode-of-action group - in which case there is no rotation, only continuous pressure on one and the same target.
IRAC states the rule unambiguously: rotate by mode-of-action group classification, not by product name.

The groups livestock production actually works with
| Active substance | IRAC group | Mechanism | Products |
|---|---|---|---|
| Azamethiphos | 1B | Organophosphate; acetylcholinesterase inhibition | TINOKS, SHEILA |
| Cypermethrin | 3A | Pyrethroid; voltage-gated sodium channel modulator | VESPA, BAGSTER EU |
| Prallethrin | 3A | Type I pyrethroid; the same mechanism | BAGSTER EU (in combination) |
| Cyphenothrin | 3A | Pyrethroid; the same mechanism | CHAMELEON FUMIGENO |
The main point of the table. Cypermethrin, prallethrin and cyphenothrin all belong to group 3A. Moving from one to another is not rotation: the target is the same, and resistance mechanisms developed against one automatically work against the other two. The only genuine change of mode of action among these four substances is between azamethiphos (1B) and any pyrethroid (3A).

How resistance works in the fly
Musca domestica has documented resistance to carbamates (group 1A), organophosphates (1B), pyrethroids (3A), neonicotinoids (4A) and spinosyns (5). The mechanisms fall into two types.
Target-site change
For pyrethroids these are mutations in the voltage-gated sodium channel gene - known as kdr, super-kdr and kdr-his. Scott’s review (2017) records their spread worldwide. A 2026 study in Japanese livestock barns found sodium channel mutations and acetylcholinesterase gene duplication in the same populations - resistance to two groups at once.
For organophosphates the equivalent is an altered acetylcholinesterase with reduced sensitivity to inhibition.
Metabolic resistance
The insect detoxifies the active substance faster. For pyrethroids, overexpression of cytochrome P450 CYP6D1 plays the key role, and it works independently of kdr. For azamethiphos, Danish researchers identified a combination of oxidative and hydrolytic mechanisms together with an altered acetylcholinesterase.
The good news: resistance can be reversible
For azamethiphos, the Danish work showed something important: resistance reverts in the absence of selection pressure. A population not treated with that substance for several seasons gradually regains susceptibility.
That turns rotation from a formal requirement into a working tool. Give a group a season off and the proportion of resistant individuals in the population falls - provided numbers are held down by other means in the meantime.
A practical rotation scheme
The minimum workable scheme for a farm looks like this:
| Period | Group | What to use |
|---|---|---|
| Season 1, or the first half of the season | 1B | Azamethiphos: pheromone bait for adults, spraying of resting sites |
| Season 2, or the second half of the season | 3A | Pyrethroids: emulsifiable concentrate for residual treatment, smoke generator for the volume |
| Continuously, in parallel | No group | Sanitation, substrate moisture control, sticky ribbons for counting |
A few rules that make the scheme work:
- One group per period, in full. Mixing groups within a cycle destroys the point of rotating.
- Change group no sooner than a full population development cycle, or the new generation is exposed to both groups at once.
- Do not under-dose. Sub-toxic concentrations are the most efficient way to breed a resistant population, because the survivors are precisely the carriers of resistance mechanisms.
- Always run the non-chemical measures. Rotation without sanitation merely postpones the inevitable: a population that keeps rebuilding is permanently under selection.
- Record what was used and when. Without a log there is no way of knowing how many seasons running you have pressed on one group.
Be careful with trade names and labels
Two practical traps.
The first. The same brand can have a different composition in different countries. A well-known fly control product, for example, is based on azamethiphos in one jurisdiction and on thiamethoxam with the same (Z)-9-tricosene pheromone in another. Those are entirely different IRAC groups - 1B and 4A. So rates and strategy are always checked against the current national label of the specific batch, not against a name someone once memorised.
The second. Combination products containing two substances from the same group (cypermethrin and prallethrin, both 3A, for instance) give synergy in speed of action, but they are not a combination of mechanisms for anti-resistance purposes.
How to spot the problem starting
- The effect lasts less: the same application “holds” noticeably less time than a year ago.
- Flies land on a freshly treated surface and do not die.
- Treatment frequency has to be increased steadily while sanitary conditions are unchanged.
- The product works on young flies but not on the adult population at the end of the season.
Before concluding resistance, rule out the more mundane causes: under-concentration, absorption of the product by a porous surface, treating the wrong areas rather than where flies actually land, and, most often, an unresolved problem with wet substrate that keeps supplying new generations. Covered in detail in the article on fly biology and control strategy.
The same rule applies elsewhere
The principle of rotating by mode of action is not specific to insecticides. It applies equally to rodenticides, where rotating “down” to a weaker substance accelerates selection, and to disinfectants, where adaptation of a building’s microflora to one class is a real phenomenon. The shared logic is the same: what has to change is the target, not the label.
Read also
Products for this task are in the Insecticides section.
Sources
- IRAC International MoA Working Group. IRAC Mode of Action Classification Scheme - groups 1B and 3A.
- IRAC. Housefly - Musca domestica: groups with documented resistance, and the recommendation to rotate by group rather than product name.
- Scott J.G. Evolution of resistance to pyrethroid insecticides in Musca domestica. Pest Management Science, 2017; 73:716.
- Kristensen M., Knorr M., Spencer A.G., Jespersen J.B. Selection and Reversion of Azamethiphos-Resistance in a Field Population of the Housefly Musca domestica, and the Underlying Biochemical Mechanisms. Journal of Economic Entomology, 2000; 93(6):1788-1795.
- Full-length coding sequence analysis of the voltage-gated sodium channel and acetylcholinesterase genes reveals target-site mutations and acetylcholinesterase gene duplication in housefly populations in Japanese livestock barns. Medical and Veterinary Entomology, 2026.
- Insecticide resistance level and geographical distribution of target-site mutations in field collections of the house fly (Musca domestica) from Türkiye. Ecotoxicology, 2026.
- AERU, University of Hertfordshire. Pesticide Properties DataBase - azamethiphos and cypermethrin profiles.
Note. IRAC groups are given per the current classification scheme. The composition of a specific product should be checked against the national label for the batch. Insecticides are used in accordance with the manufacturer’s instructions.


